Smells amazing, lovely quality, soft and durable, my 1 year old loves itThe first order came in with the plastic containers cracked. It also came with 2 blue and 1 yellow. Return was super simple and replacement came within a couple of days. Unfortunately, the replacement didn't come with the red clay either. Pretty disappointed that we are only able to make green. Will likely purchase again from another company.Wow this version is TERRIBLE! Very strong chemical smell and is an impossible consistency to play with. The old ones were great, was surprised to see such a bad product.This product arrives damaged. The blue doughs lid was broken causing it to not he able to close and dry out right away.The odor i so strong, it's hard to use. The consistency of the blue and yellow is easy to work with, but the red was so sticky we couldn't use it at all.This dough feels soft. It does NOT have a pleasant smell. AND it STAINS. It stained my table in the classroom. I had to use a melamine pad to get it off the table.Just stay with what works.We love Eco Dough. Uses natural-based dyes instead of artificial ones and feels soft to the touch.My kids do so much more with this larger tub. Colors are different but fine. Do soft and seems like therapy for my kids with the larger amount.